The Idiocy of Idealism by Oscar Levy, 1940, William Hodge and Company Ltd, 155 pp.
The Revival of Aristocracy by Oscar Levy, 1906, Probsthain, 119 pp.
In 1938, from a villa on the Côte d’Azur, Oscar Levy composed an open letter titled “The Excommunication of Adolf Hitler.” Its purpose was to sever Hitler from Nietzsche, and its means were as incendiary as they were bewildering: Levy pronounced the Führer a victim of “Jewish values” and an “Untermensch from a Nietzschean perspective.” The letter went unpublished—Levy had relatives still in Germany—but it survives as the clearest statement of a project he had pursued for three decades: to make Nietzsche the property of an aristocratic, anti-egalitarian elite, and to keep him from German nationalists, whom Levy regarded not as Nietzsche’s heirs but as his vulgarizers. Hitler had by then endowed the Nietzsche Archive at Weimar and accepted the gift of the philosopher’s walking stick, so that demonstrating the vulgar, un-Nietzschean character of National Socialism had become, for Levy, an urgent task.
Levy’s case is instructive and worth recovering now because it shows that opposition to National Socialism did not require, and in his instance explicitly rejected the egalitarian premises that later became almost definitional of antifascism. He was no reflexive enemy of authoritarian rule: he had known Mussolini personally, interviewed him for the New York Times in 1924, and warned him in 1937 against the German alliance, breaking with Il Duce only after the Lateran Treaty. He despised Hitler as a leveler and a resentful mediocrity, not as a Great Man gone wrong. To read Levy is to be reminded how much wider the field of permitted argument once was, and how strange the map of interwar opinion looks when its coordinates are not the ones we have inherited.



